With Archbishop Fulton Sheen’s beatification taking place this week, Catholics are asking about the legacy of one of the most famous bishops of the 20th century.
So what do we think?
In this week's Remnant Underground, Michael gives his candid take on Fulton Sheen and on the enormous revolution in the Catholic Church that Sheen lived through but did not live long enough to see fully unfold.
Sheen died in 1979.
He never saw Assisi.
He never saw Pachamama.
He never saw Fiducia Supplicans.
He never saw the destruction of the Catholic sanctuary or the increasingly disturbing treatment of the Blessed Sacrament that Michael examines in this episode.
But Michael also refuses to turn Sheen into either a Traditionalist mascot or a Modernist villain.
Michael’s own father, Walter Matt, knew Sheen personally. The Remnant's files contain letters from Sheen during the years when the two men were at odds over Vatican II.
And the reason for that disagreement?
The Revolution.
To help put Archbishop Sheen in his proper historical context, Michael also revisits the remarkable Catholic debates of an earlier era, including William F. Buckley Jr.'s interviews with Michael Davies and Archbishop Lefebvre—when Catholics could still debate the crisis in the Church openly, seriously, and without today's constant name-calling.
But this just goes to show: The Revolution was hotly debated and the confusion good men felt over the turn of events was palpable.
Watch the new Remnant Underground and hear Michael Matt's take on Fulton Sheen, Vatican II, the New Mass, and the revolution that Sheen never lived to see:
Please help us make the CIC Livestream happen.
Subscribe to Remnant Newspaper
Sign up for Michael Matt’s E-Letter
SOURCE VIDEOS:
Firing Line with William F. Buckley & Archbishop Fulton Sheen
Firing Line with William F. Buckley & Michael Davies
Stand with Bishops Schneider and Mutsaerts at the Catholic Identity Conference!
Subscribe to Remnant Newspaper
This week, Pope Leo is giving a dusty old Vatican II document, Nostra Aetate, a little time in the spotlight.
Why Nostra Aetate, and why now?
The real story of Vatican II is not found merely by the documents, but by following the men who wrote them.
The names are not obscure: Cardinal Joseph Suenens. Cardinal Augustin Bea. Bishop Helder Câmara. Cardinal Godfried Danneels.
And the documents are not obscure either: Nostra Aetate. Gaudium et Spes. Unitatis Redintegratio. The Catacombs Pact.
Accusations of Marxism, Freemasonry and papal election interference have swarmed the men responsible for these documents (which played a definitive role in changing the Church since 1965). Just ask Malachi Martin, once Cardinal Bea's secretary, who eventually broke with the post-conciliar inner circle and became one of the most famous traditionalist whistleblowers and also a Remnant columnist. Yes, you read that right!
In this episode of The Remnant Underground, Michael Matt follows that trail from the Second Vatican Council directly into the present day.
Six decades later, Pope Leo XIV is repeatedly emphasizing Vatican II and interreligious dialogue, and this week issued a major new document marking the 60th anniversary of Nostra Aetate. And one of the document's principal signatories? Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández…
Michael connects this renewed Vatican emphasis to their increasing intolerance of Tradition, the SSPX, and the Divine Commission of Our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ.
The real battle isn’t simply about individual documents, it’s about the Revolution those documents helped unleash.
So follow the documents. Follow the men. Follow the networks.
Then look at Rome today and decide for yourself what you see, because the ideological trajectory is remarkably easy to trace.
This episode will give you goosebumps!
Read Robert Morrison on Nostra Aetate & New Vatican Document
Sign up for Michael Matt’s E-Letter
How far does Catholic obedience go? What happens when those in authority undermine the Faith they are duty-bound to protect? Michael Matt takes the Vatican’s latest treatment of Bishop Athanasius Schneider and the Latin Mass as the starting point for asking the million-dollar question: Where is your line in the sand?
If you think disobedience to the Vatican is impossible, then you must have missed plenty of prelates doing just that and remaining in “good standing”.
From Bishops Schneider and Strickland to the entire African Bishops Conference, resistance to the Synodal agenda and recent papal encyclicals is gathering steam.
And why not? When from St. Paul in the Gospel, to Our Lady’s prophecies at La Salette and Fatima, to the warnings of Sr. Lucia and Bl. Anne Catherine Emmerich, Heaven has always prepped us to allow for a time when false prophets will arise and even the elect will be deceived…
So, answer this: Can there ever come a time when obedience itself becomes a betrayal of truth? And if that time comes, what does Christ expect of us?
Stand with Bishop Schneider at the Catholic Identity Conference!
Check out our SPONSOR! Get a Free phone from Charity Mobile
Subscribe to Remnant Newspaper
Sign up for Michael Matt's E-Letter
Subscribe to The Remnant Newspaper!
Register for the CIC here!
– Kids 12 and under come FREE
– Clergy and Religious come FREE
– Discounted Student Rate
Why is Pope Leo XIV teaching Gaudium et Spes? And what does this Vatican II document have to do with “the care of water,” synodality, the Communist Bishop Helder Câmara, Klaus Schwab and the continuing war against Tradition?
In this episode of The Remnant Underground, Michael Matt examines Pope Leo’s September prayer intention for “the care of water” and his catechetical series on the documents of Vatican II, particularly Gaudium et Spes.
Michael explores the criticisms of Bishop Athanasius Schneider, Msgr. Brunero Gherardini and others who have warned that the document placed excessive emphasis on temporal human concerns at the expense of the Church’s supernatural mission.
He also examines the controversial role of Bishop Helder Câmara, the Catacombs Pact, and how they connect Vatican II, Synodality and the postconciliar transformation of the Catholic Church.
And then there is the SSPX.
Why does the Vatican continue to fight the movement associated with Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre while so many other movements and ideologies find welcome within the Catholic Church?
Michael's answer is blunt: The issue is never the issue. The issue is ALWAYS the Revolution.
Check Out Our Sponsor—Catholic Match
Shop The Remnant Store!
SOURCES:
Robert Morrison on the Pope’s catechesis on Gaudium et spes
Gaetano Masciullo on Panentheism
Sign up for the Catholic Identity Conference: https://catholicidentityconference.org/index.php
Meet the grand-nephew of Emperor Karl -- Archduke Eduard Habsburg of Austria who will tell the true story of his uncle, the last Catholic king of Europe, and his noble attempt to save us all from a Christophobic New World Order -- an attempt for which the Emperor was banished and would eventually die a martyr's death in exile.
Blessed Karl of Austria, Pray for us.
Subscribe to Remnant Newspaper: https://www.remnantnewspaper.com/subscribe/
Support Us: https://www.remnantnewspaper.com/donate-today/
Sign up for Michael Matt's Weekly E-Letter: https://www.remnantnewspaper.com/free-remnant-updates/
End of content
No more pages to load